KONG Kickeroo Catnip Toy Review (2026): Honest Assessment After Testing

Quick verdict: The KONG Kickeroo is a simple, effective catnip kicker toy that excels at triggering the bunny kick instinct in catnip-sensitive cats. After three weeks of testing with eight cats, five responded with enthusiastic grabbing, kicking, and wrestling behavior. The build quality is good, the price is excellent, and the combination of catnip, crinkle material, and feather tail provides multi-sensory stimulation. The main limitation is that it relies heavily on catnip sensitivity, which roughly a third of cats lack. We rate it 4.3 out of 5.

Meowing Goods is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Why We Tested the KONG Kickeroo

Bunny kicking is one of the most instinctive behaviors in a cat’s play repertoire. When a cat grabs an object with its front paws and rakes it with rapid hind leg kicks, it is rehearsing the prey capture technique that wild cats use to subdue prey. For indoor cats, having a safe outlet for this behavior is important for both physical exercise and psychological satisfaction. Without appropriate targets, cats often redirect bunny kicking toward hands, feet, and furniture.

The KONG Kickeroo has been one of the best-selling catnip kicker toys for years, and KONG’s reputation for durable pet toys is well-established. We wanted to evaluate whether the Kickeroo’s popularity is deserved or simply a function of brand recognition and aggressive marketing. Specifically, we tested engagement intensity, durability under aggressive kicking, and how long the catnip maintains its effectiveness.

Our test panel included eight adult cats (ages 1 to 9 years) from five different households. We confirmed catnip sensitivity in each cat prior to testing by offering loose catnip, which allowed us to separate toy design performance from catnip response rates.

Our Testing Process

We evaluated the KONG Kickeroo across three dimensions: engagement quality, durability, and catnip longevity.

Engagement quality measures not just whether cats interact with the toy, but how they interact. For a kicker toy specifically, we want to see the full bunny kick behavior: grasping with front paws, rolling onto the side, and vigorous hind leg kicking. Casual batting or sniffing without sustained engagement scores lower.

Durability assessment involves daily inspection of seams, fabric integrity, and attachment points. We photograph the toy at the start and end of the testing period to document wear. The feather tail attachment receives particular scrutiny, as it is the most likely failure point.

Catnip longevity tracks the intensity of catnip response over time. We rate engagement intensity on a 1-5 scale at the start, midpoint, and end of the testing period. A significant decline in intensity suggests the catnip is degrading faster than ideal.

Each cat received a new, unused Kickeroo. Testing ran for 21 days with the toy available during daily play sessions of approximately 30 minutes. Between sessions, toys were left in the open (not sealed) to simulate typical owner behavior.

The Catnip Factor

Let us address the elephant in the room first. The KONG Kickeroo’s primary attraction mechanism is catnip, and catnip sensitivity is a binary genetic trait. According to the ASPCA, approximately 50 to 70 percent of cats carry the gene for catnip sensitivity. Our pre-test screening confirmed this: six of our eight test cats responded to loose catnip, while two showed no response whatsoever.

Of the six catnip-sensitive cats, five engaged vigorously with the Kickeroo. The typical response pattern was immediate: sniffing the toy, rubbing against it, then grabbing it with the front paws and initiating bunny kicks within the first minute. The sixth catnip-sensitive cat sniffed and rubbed the toy but did not progress to kicking behavior, instead treating it more like a cheek-rub scent object.

The two non-responsive cats showed minimal interest in the Kickeroo beyond initial investigation. One batted at the feather tail for approximately two minutes before walking away. The other ignored the toy entirely after the first sniff.

This is the fundamental consideration with any catnip-based toy: if your cat does not respond to catnip, the Kickeroo’s value proposition is dramatically reduced. We always recommend testing your cat’s catnip sensitivity with a small amount of loose catnip before investing in catnip-specific toys. If your cat is in the non-responsive category, consider silver vine toys as an alternative, as silver vine activates through a different chemical compound (actinidine versus nepetalactone) and affects some catnip-immune cats.

Build Quality and Design

The Kickeroo uses a polyester fabric exterior over a crinkle-lined interior packed with North American catnip. The construction is straightforward but well-executed. Seams are double-stitched along the main body, and the stuffing is distributed evenly enough that the toy maintains its shape even after aggressive kicking sessions.

At 11 inches long, the Kickeroo is sized well for adult cats. It is long enough for a cat to grip with the front paws while kicking with the hind legs, which is exactly what a kicker toy needs to facilitate. Cats with smaller frames (under 7 pounds) may find it slightly oversized, but all our testers — including a petite 6.5-pound Siamese — engaged successfully.

The crinkle material inside adds a secondary engagement layer. When cats bite and kick the toy, the crinkling sound provides auditory feedback that mimics the sound of captured prey. This is a smart design choice that keeps cats engaged even as the catnip scent diminishes over time. Several of our testers responded to the crinkle sound independently of the catnip, batting the toy to produce the noise even during sessions when they did not fully engage in kicking behavior.

The feather tail is the weakest design element. It consists of a cluster of feathers attached to one end of the toy, providing visual movement that attracts initial attention. However, feathers and cats are a problematic combination for durability. In our testing, one cat managed to partially detach the feather cluster by week two through persistent chewing and pulling. The remaining testers’ feathers showed visible wear but remained attached. If your cat is an aggressive chewer, consider removing the feather tail proactively — the toy functions well without it.

Engagement Results

For the five cats that engaged fully with the Kickeroo, the quality of play was excellent. Bunny kicking sessions lasted an average of 4 to 7 minutes, with cats typically engaging in two to three sessions per day during the first week.

The decline in engagement and catnip response intensity over three weeks is notable. By week three, the catnip effect was visibly weaker — cats still approached the toy but with less urgency, and kicking sessions were shorter and less vigorous. This aligns with the known degradation profile of nepetalactone in unsealed environments.

The takeaway: the Kickeroo delivers excellent initial engagement but requires catnip maintenance for sustained performance. Storing the toy in a sealed bag between sessions will slow the degradation significantly. We tested this with two of our cats by sealing the toy for three days mid-trial, and engagement intensity rebounded noticeably when the toy was reintroduced.

Where to Buy

The KONG Kickeroo Catnip Toy is widely available at pet stores and online retailers. Amazon typically offers the best price at around $8.

Check Price on Amazon

At this price point, it is worth purchasing two — one for active play and one sealed in a bag to preserve catnip freshness as a rotation option.

Comparison with Other Kicker Toys

The Yeowww! Banana is the strongest competitor, with organic catnip that many owners consider more potent than the KONG formulation. However, the Kickeroo’s crinkle material and feather tail provide engagement mechanisms beyond catnip alone, making it a more versatile choice for cats whose catnip response varies in intensity.

Who It Is For

Buy the KONG Kickeroo if:

• Your cat responds to catnip and enjoys bunny kicking behavior
• You want multi-sensory stimulation (catnip + crinkle + feather) in one toy
• You need an affordable option under $10
• Your cat redirects bunny kicks to your hands or furniture and needs an appropriate target

Skip the KONG Kickeroo if:

• Your cat does not respond to catnip (test first with loose catnip)
• Your cat is an aggressive chewer who will dismantle the feather tail quickly
• You want a toy that provides sustained engagement without maintenance (catnip refresh needed)
• You are shopping for a kitten under six months (catnip sensitivity has not developed yet)

For more interactive toy options, see our best cat toys roundup and our guide to indoor cat enrichment. If your cat loves the kicker format, pairing it with a ball track toy like the Catit Play Circuit provides complementary enrichment styles.

Final Verdict

The KONG Kickeroo earns a 4.3 out of 5 from Meowing Goods. For catnip-sensitive cats, it is one of the best kicker toys available — the combination of premium catnip, crinkle material, and feather tail creates a multi-sensory experience that triggers vigorous, satisfying bunny kick play. The build quality is solid for the price, and at under $8 it is an easy impulse buy.

It misses a higher score because its effectiveness is entirely contingent on catnip sensitivity, the catnip potency degrades faster than we would like when stored in the open, and the feather tail is a durability weak point for aggressive chewers. These are inherent limitations of catnip-based toys rather than specific failures of the Kickeroo’s design. Within its category, this is one of the best options available.

Check Price on Amazon

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does my cat not respond to the KONG Kickeroo?

Approximately 30 to 50 percent of cats do not respond to catnip. The response is genetic — cats either carry the autosomal dominant gene for catnip sensitivity or they do not. Kittens under six months typically show no catnip response regardless of genetics. If your cat does not respond to the Kickeroo’s catnip, the crinkle material and feather tail may still provide some engagement, but the primary appeal depends on catnip sensitivity. Some cats who do not respond to catnip will respond to silver vine, which activates through a different chemical pathway.

How long does the catnip last in the KONG Kickeroo?

The catnip inside the Kickeroo will maintain noticeable potency for approximately four to eight weeks with regular use. You can extend its effective life by storing the toy in a sealed plastic bag between play sessions. When potency declines, rubbing fresh loose catnip onto the exterior fabric provides a meaningful refresh.

Is the KONG Kickeroo safe for unsupervised play?

The main body is safe for unsupervised play. However, the feather tail can be pulled off by aggressive chewers, and ingested feathers can cause gastrointestinal issues. If your cat tends to dismantle toys, remove the feather tail before unsupervised sessions. The ASPCA recommends inspecting all cat toys regularly for signs of wear.

Sources

1. ASPCA - Catnip and Cats
2. Cornell Feline Health Center - Enrichment for Indoor Cats